Book Review: The Pillow Book of the Flower Samurai
Although I have written about books here and there before, I thought introducing some book reviews to this blog might be a nice idea. I love to read, but reading took a backseat when my work ramped up and I resorted to trash TV to relax – something I really want to change! I love to read books related to travel, so I have quite a few that have stayed in my mind and that I want to recommend… so expect to see a few more book reviews related to my favourite destinations here. With Japan being my favourite destination at the moment, let’s start with a novel set in Japan.
I have been writing on a post about books on Japan, which has been growing longer and more convoluted, so I thought maybe, some separate book reviews are in order. I am unsure how this series will pan out, but, let’s just make a start.. Having bought and read some books that I felt were a waste of my time and money, I thought maybe some of you might find these book reviews helpful before spending money on a book.
So this is not the best book, nor the most memorable, but I got to start somewhere. Regarding Japanese literature, I have so far stuck to a few well-known contemporary novels, starting with Kazuo Ishiguro in the 1990s (very accessible, easily written in English), moved on to Haruki Murakami (not much luck) and various other “books of the moment” that I generally enjoyed. So, why start with this? It is just the book I read most recently. More to come.
I have read and enjoyed a “smaller” Japan-centred blog in German which has loads of book reviews, and I regularly look there for new inspiration. If you can read German, I really recommend looking there for reading inspiration. Problem is, when you go looking for it, you will always find “big” blogs which can look quite generic. I initially came across it on Instagram, but I prefer reading the blog.
The photographs, by the way, are all from the Rokuhara area of Kyoto, where part of this novel is set, taken mostly in February 2026 when I stayed in the Rokuhara area – highly recommended, close to sights yet not very crowded.
Table of Contents
About the novel
This novel is a rather lengthy work (480 pages) of historical fiction set in the 12th Century, making this late Heian period. Starting off rather unspecific with no relation to historical events, it later threads into the Genpei War, a civil conflict between two prominent clans of the Heian era, the Taira and the Minamoto.
The blurb on the cover reads “Memoirs of a Geisha meets Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon – The Pillow Book of the Flower Samurai is a gorgeously vivid, fresh historical that instantly captures the imagination” Hmmm… that’s a lot of superlatives, innit, especially when we consider the aforementioned are set in totally different eras and different places. However, both of those being not exactly heavyweight (but sold well, eh), I should have possibly been warned.

About the Author
There is very little around – only that Barbara Lazar’s first career appears to be mainframe developing after a literary degree. There is an author website but it was shown on my computer (Firefox, eh) as non-https, so I’ve not visited. A bit strange for a writer whose main gig appears to be software programming. The most detailed information on the author came from Amazon, of all places. As far as I could see, this is her only published novel to date.

My opinion of “The Pillow Book of the Flower Samurai”
First of all, this book is an easy read, and, when you first pick it up, it moves quite fluidly, gathering interest, as the first chapter is one of very few written from the perspective of anyone but the main character.
Even when the main character starts right at the beginning, being a small girl in a poor farming family, it feels charming, and although a large number of characters are introduced over a few pages, it flows quite naturally. Sadly, after twenty pages or so, the fluid and quite charming storytelling quickly loses momentum, and you will have to wade through another four hundred-odd pages of linear first-person narrator storytelling. After another twenty pages, the linearity of the story really bothered me to the point of becoming tedious.
Since this was strictly my bedtime read, I didn’t mind that this was a somewhat simple linear story, but a work of literature it ain’t. Other reviewers have criticised the author for naming characters that one would not find in Heian era records, and that it felt inauthentic for a story set in the Heian era. I have very little knowledge of historical details, so I could not comment on that. However, the “pillow book” is a very common description when one discusses Heian literature, and I feel it’s too much piggybacking on the historical Pillow book of Sei Shonagon”, a historical author and lady of the court. This novel isn’t about books, and the main character bemoans frequently how bad her writing skills ar, so her producing a “pillow book” in the first place is somewhat unrealistic.
There are historical records of female practising samurai (so called Onna-musha, 女武者), and there are records that these go back as far as the late Heian area and in particular the Genpei War which features heavily later in the book, so well, fine, female samurai appear to have existed for real, but I found “Flower Samurai” a bit… flowery, and team that with the much-used “Pillow Book” you get a fairly cliche-riddled title.
Another thing that irritated the heck out of me is giving “code names” to some of the characters. Having a list of characters in the book is all very well, but I never understood these half-assed code names that were given to some, but not others, especially members of the Minamoto clan mentioned in the book, with their very similar-sounding names. Are these code names just slapped on for the ease of readers, or were they a thing in Heian-era Japan? Who knows, but they look a bit silly in the novel.
So, I did not terribly enjoy this book. I started reading in parallel with ” The Makioka Sisters” and I read the much more heavygoing Tanizaki Opus Magnum more easily and with more joy than this. Admittedly, have yet to finish the last few pages, to be honest, but the first chapter, which, while making a good introduction to the book, acts as one big spoiler, so one knows what is going to happen, and the motivation to finish the book remains low. So it comes as no surprise that this novel did not win any awards or appeared on a bestseller list. I am surprised it even made it to paperback edition, to be honest.
To me, the book feels very much like a vanity project – although the author has a educational background in literature, her main job appeared technical or scientific, and this is pretty much how this book feels – a bit like a paper one would publish in those pay-per-page journals, a bit easy and unidimensional. I found it relatively easy to read, as a non-native speaker, although others have complained that the language and structuring is inelegant. Maybe I just speed read it too fast once I got too bored, but well, I think some good editing may have made this book tighter, but not necessarily better in terms of the original story and the unidimensional, linear way it is told.

Book Details
The novel was first published in 2013 by Headline. The original language is English. As far as I am aware, there are no translations available. The book’s ISBN for the paperback is 075538928X. I bought mine easily and cheaply from a secondhand bookseller on the web.

Read this book if you…
Oh, I really don’t know. Maybe, if you like historic novels set in Heian-era Japan with female protagonists and the Tale of Genji is a bit too much. I consider it a very lightweight read. Okay if you want something super-easy.
The Small Print
This review reflect my personal opinion of the material read, which I purchased. I am no literature critic, just someone who enjoys reading.
I am not putting in Amazon links here, because I try not to buy from them any more, so why trying to monetize through something I don’t use myself. I tend to buy used, or from a German bookshop called Thalia, but want to buy more from independent bookshops in the future, so I am looking into geniallokal and uk.bookshop.org. But I haven’t really figured out how to set up an account, and, to be honest, this novel is no recommendation from me, so why bother.
If you want to buy it, please support your local bookshop or independent booksellers and buy from there or buy secondhand!
I’ve included just a single affiliate link to the hostel I stayed at in the Rokuhara area. If you feel I saved you some money and time NOT reading it, and you want to support this blog, please feel free to read some other posts, and get this blog seen. If you want to support this blog even more, some other posts contain affiliate links to accommodation, but if you don’t, that’s fine